Fifth Circuit Rules Second Amendment Protects Firearm Sales in Major Federal Gun Case

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit delivered a significant victory for the Second Amendment on November 19, ruling that the constitutional right to keep and bear arms also protects the sale of firearms. The decision rejects the notion that the federal government can regulate firearm commerce without implicating the constitutional rights of gun owners, buyers, and sellers.

In United States v. Deare, No. 24-30241, a three-judge panel vacated a lower court’s decision denying a constitutional challenge to federal firearms-dealer licensing requirements and sent the case back for further proceedings. Although the ruling does not invalidate federal dealer-licensing laws, it establishes an important constitutional principle: The Second Amendment’s protections extend beyond simply possessing and carrying firearms.

“The plain text of the Second Amendment covers the sale of firearms,” the court declared in its published opinion.

Perhaps even more revealing, the federal government conceded during oral arguments that the Second Amendment applies to the commercial sale of firearms. That concession, combined with the court’s holding, undercuts the argument that restrictions on firearm transactions can automatically escape constitutional scrutiny merely because Congress characterizes them as commercial regulations.

Federal Firearms Prosecution Leads to Second Amendment Challenge

The case centers on Jeremiah Micah Deare, who was indicted in the Western District of Louisiana for conspiracy to engage in the business of dealing firearms without a federal firearms license (FFL), in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 922(a)(1). He also faced charges involving false statements concerning the records of federally licensed firearms dealers.

Deare challenged the constitutionality of the federal licensing requirement and related record-keeping provisions, arguing that they violated the Second Amendment. The district court rejected his challenge, concluding that licensing and record-keeping requirements did not implicate the right to keep and bear arms because they regulated commercial activity rather than firearm possession.

The district court also concluded that the licensing requirements were consistent with the nation’s historical tradition of firearm regulation. Deare subsequently went to trial, where a jury convicted him on all counts. He received a sentence of 97 months in federal prison.

On appeal, Deare argued that the lower court had incorrectly excluded firearm sales from the Second Amendment’s protections. The Fifth Circuit agreed that the constitutional analysis could not end simply because the challenged provisions regulated firearm commerce.

Citing its earlier decision in Reese v. ATF, the court explained that the right to possess firearms necessarily includes the ability to acquire them. The appellate judges therefore vacated the district court’s denial of Deare’s motion to dismiss and remanded the case for additional proceedings.

Continue reading “”

History does not provide any example of capital accumulation brought about by a government. As far as governments invested in the construction of roads, railroads, and other useful public works, the capital needed was provided by the savings of individual citizens and borrowed by the government.
– Ludwig von Mises

When Artificial Intelligence Starts Watching Gun Owners

Americans have spent decades fighting to protect their Second Amendment rights from government overreach. We’ve challenged unconstitutional gun laws, fought registration schemes, and pushed back against politicians who treat lawful gun ownership like suspicious behavior. Now there’s another threat worth paying attention to, and this one doesn’t require Congress to pass a single gun control law. It requires artificial intelligence, access to millions of images, and a federal agency with a troubling history of surveillance. Meet the FBI’s Project Tyr.

What Is Project Tyr?

In January 2024, the Department of Justice disclosed an FBI initiative called Project Tyr in its publicly available Artificial Intelligence Use Case Inventory. The project involves Amazon Rekognition, an artificial intelligence system capable of analyzing images and videos to identify objects, activities, and other visual information. According to the government’s disclosure, the FBI intended to customize the technology to identify nudity, weapons, explosives, and other information in lawfully acquired images and videos.

Weapons.

That single word should get the attention of every American who owns a firearm, teaches firearms safety, competes in shooting sports, or advocates for the Second Amendment. Because while the FBI describes a tool designed to identify objects, the implications extend far beyond identifying a gun in a photograph.Technology raises an important question: What happens when the federal government can use artificial intelligence to identify firearms across enormous collections of digital images?

Your Gun Photos Could Become Government Data

Continue reading “”

Hearing witness accuses ATF of defying Congress by building 1.4 billion-record gun registry

 The director of federal affairs for Gun Owners of America (GOA) accused the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives (ATF) of ignoring laws that prohibited the creation of a firearms registry through digitized records of firearms sales in testimony Wednesday.

“I am here to tell you that ATF has ignored Congress. The national data bank [Republican Ohio] Congressman [Del] Latta warned about now exists. Right now, in a record center in Martinsburg, West Virginia, the ATF holds more than 1.4 billion records that identify which Americans own which guns,” GOA Director of Federal Affairs Aidan Johnston told the House Oversight Committee’s subcommittee on federal law enforcement during a Wednesday hearing. “Those records are searchable and they can be weaponized against law abiding gun owners for mass gun confiscation. Gun Owners of America spent years exposing ATF’s registry because it is a direct threat to the right of the people to keep and bear arms.”

ATF keeps at least 866 million digitalized records from federally licensed firearms dealers (FFLs), according to Reason Magazine, which have been the subject of allegations from pro-Second Amendment organizations that the agency has created a “backdoor gun registry.” Johnston told the committee the number reached over 1.4 billion records as of May and that it would take less than a day to allow the agency to search the records by name.

“Here’s how ATF’s registry works. After a firearm is serialized, the manufacturer records which dealer received it. The dealer then records which individual bought it using the information collected on the background check form 4473,” Johnston told the subcommittee. “The buyer gives his or her full name, address, date of birth, height, weight, and race. The dealer then records the make, model, and serial number of the gun. What many gun owners do not realize is that when the dealer closes, every single firearm transaction record is sent to ATF. ATF then digitizes these transaction records into a centralized database it calls the out of business record imaging system. In May of this year, ATF reported that it maintains 1,414,088,513 of these gun and gun owner records.”

ATF argued that the record retention was in compliance with federal law in a statement to the Daily Caller News Foundation. No ATF officials testified during the hearing.

“Federal law requires firearms dealers that go out of business to send their records to ATF, and federal law prohibits ATF from creating a registry or electronically searching those records by name,” an ATF spokesperson told the DCNF. “Numerous GAO reports and IG reports have verified that ATF complies with the law. The records are used for one purpose: tracing guns recovered in crimes, by serial number, for the investigating law enforcement agency. In May, ATF for the first time proposed limiting how long it keeps these records. That rulemaking is ongoing.”

GOA and ATF clashed in July over a proposal by ATF to reduce record retention requirements to 30 years for both federally licensed firearm dealers (FFL) and for the agency. According to the ATF’s proposal, the rules would shift to be closer in line with the rules in place after 1985, which mandated a 20-year retention of records.

In 2022, the Biden administration altered the regulations to require retention of records until the Federal Firearms Licensee discontinued the business.

Second Amendment Org Sues New Mexico After State Defies Court Ruling On Gun Waiting Period

A pro-Second Amendment organization [FPC] took New Mexico to court Wednesday, accusing it of defying a federal appeals court.


One (1) day later………

New Mexico Throws In Towel After Second Suit Over Gun Waiting Period

New Mexico agreed to stop enforcing a seven-day waiting period for firearms purchases Thursday, a pro-Second Amendment group announced.

In an Oct. 19 complaint, the National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF), National Rifle Association (NRA), Second Amendment Foundation (SAF) and the New Mexico Shooting Sports Association accused Democratic New Mexico Attorney General Raul Torrez of circumventing an Aug. 28 grant of summary judgment by declaring a ruling from the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit only applied to the plaintiffs. The state agreed to not enforce the waiting period in a joint motion filed Wednesday.

“Defendant, and all those subject to his supervision, will be immediately enjoined from enforcing and/or implementing House Bill 129 pending final resolution of Plaintiffs’ Second Amendment claim, unless the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit issues a decision in the interim holding that House Bill 129 is constitutional and a final mandate in Ortega v. Grisham, No. 26-2170, reversing the district court’s grant of summary judgment in favor of the plaintiffs in that case,” the motion states.

“We’re thrilled that New Mexico has agreed to halt enforcement of its unconstitutional waiting period and restore the fundamental rights of its residents,” SAF Senior Director of Legal Operations Bill Sack said in a Thursday release. “It’s unclear why state officials insisted on enforcing the law despite the Ortega ruling, and necessitated this additional lawsuit be filed, but we’re appreciative that those same officials saw the error of their ways and have reversed course.”

The United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit struck down a waiting period on firearms purchases in August 2025 while overruling a decision in favor of New Mexico by Senior United States District Judge James O. Browning, a George W. Bush appointee.

After the district court granted summary judgment in the initial case following the Tenth Circuit’s decision, New Mexico officials declared that the ruling only applied to plaintiffs Paul Ortega and Rebecca Scott.

“The order only states that the two named plaintiffs are able to purchase firearms without having to go through the waiting period. The law remains in effect otherwise,” Michael Coleman, communications director for Democratic Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham, told Source NM.

In a Wednesday complaint filed by the Firearms Policy Coalition (FPC), the group accused the state of continuing to enforce the “obviously unconstitutional” seven-day waiting period.

Have Gun, Will Travel: Interstate Carry Reciprocity Could Be Next Major Second Amendment Showdown

Pro-Second Amendment groups are eyeing a new legal campaign, even before the Supreme Court has heard a case involving bans on modern semiautomatic firearms.

The Supreme Court agreed to hear Viramontes v. Cook County on June 30, where the justices could strike down bans on modern semiautomatic firearms like the AR-15 rifle. While the Supreme Court will hear oral arguments in Viramontes v. Cook County on Dec. 2 and expects to issue its decision on the case in summer 2027, the Second Amendment Foundation (SAF) said it was planning its next legal campaign around concealed carry reciprocity.

“After hardware bans, carry reciprocity may very well be the next main goal of our movement,” SAF posted Tuesday on X where it announced the release of a fact sheet on reciprocity.

Securing out-of-state permits for most of the country can be an expensive undertaking. In two videos posted on YouTube, one from January 2023, the other from March, Chad Albrecht, the owner of School of the American Rifle based out of Elkton, Maryland, revealed he spent over $12,000 to secure permits from 46 states and Washington, D.C.

Legal action has already been taken over some states’ refusal to allow non-residents to carry firearms for personal protection.

Liberty Justice Center filed a petition on Aug. 24 asking the high court to hear Johnson v. Jacobsen, regarding Minnesota’s refusal to recognize a long-haul truck driver’s concealed carry permits from Florida and Georgia. Although SAF filed a “friend of the court” brief alongside other pro-Second Amendment organizations, the Supreme Court declined to hear the case on Oct. 5.

“Earlier this year, this Court explained how a hypothetical young woman would struggle trying to exercise her right to carry in Hawaii,” SAF wrote in its brief. “Imagine if that same young woman also frequently travels and wants to carry a firearm to defend herself in each state she visited. The monetary cost of acquiring a permit in every state that requires one, to say nothing of the time investment, would be astronomical. Interstate visitors are Americans, yet states like Minnesota treat them like suspect foreigners that need to be re-vetted before exercising a fundamental right.”

Gun Owners of America (GOA) and the group’s Oregon state director, Cynthia Ladd, sued the city of Salem, Oregon, and Marion County, Oregon, Sheriff Nick Hunter in the United States District Court for the District of Oregon in September, asking that the state’s ban on non-residents carrying firearms be ruled a violation of the Second Amendment.

Attorneys for the state of Massachusetts failed to convince a federal judge to dismiss a lawsuit that accused the state of delaying the processing of carry permits for out-of-state residents. In an Aug. 28 ruling, Chief United States District Judge Denise Casper of the District of Massachusetts, an Obama appointee, allowed the litigation to proceed.

Harvard Study: One in Seven American Gun Owners Had an AR-15 or Similar Rifle in 2024

A Harvard study focused on “common use” claims for AR-15s and similar rifles found one in seven gun owners had an AR-15 in 2024.

The researchers introduced their findings by writing:

In June 2026, the U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear challenges to state bans on military-style semiautomatic rifles, the class commonly called AR-15 platform rifles.

Whether such rifles are in common use for lawful purposes is contested in those cases. The evidence invoked on both sides focuses in part on the number of these rifles produced or in circulation, yet any such count is consistent with either broad ownership or accumulation by relatively few owners.

They then presented their data, drawn from the 2024 National Firearms Survey. The data showed there were roughly 21 million privately owned AR-15s and similar rifles in 2024 and that approximately ten million Americans owned at least one of them.

This meant one in seven gun owners had an AR-15 or similar rifle at that time.

By subscribing, you agree to our terms of use & privacy policy. You will receive email marketing messages from Breitbart News Network to the email you provide. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Moreover, 97.5 percent of those who owned AR-15s and similar rifles “also owned at least one handgun.”

The Harvard researchers admitted their findings presented a lower number of AR-15s and similar rifles in private hands than previous research by others had found.

They confessed that despite precautions, “nonresponse bias [remained] possible” in their survey.

To gain some perspective on how low the Harvard study’s numbers could be, recall that Breitbart News pointed to National Shooting Sports Foundation (NSSF) estimates that there were nearly 20 million AR/AK-Style firearms in circulation in 2020, and that number grew to  24,446,000 in 2022.

On January 15, 2026, NSSF data indicated there were more than 32 million guns which Democrats label “assault weapons” in Americans’ hands.

On September 1, 2026, Breitbart News pointed to Georgetown University’s William English, whose research showed Americans owned approximately 60 million guns that fall into the Democrats’ category of “assault weapons.”